Bravo for Walter Jones, Goodbye Republic

Not only has the North Carolina congressman come to see the Iraq War as folly, he was one of only a handful of Republicans to oppose the torture bill. The honor roll also includes Roscoe Bartlett, Wayne Gilchrest, Steven LaTourette, James Leach, Jerry Moran, and of course Ron Paul. Along with most of the Democratic caucus.

Notice anyone missing from that list? On Bovard’s blog, “libertarian” Jeff Flake’s absence was noted. But I was most surprised — and sickened — by John Duncan’s pro-torture vote. He’s an antiwar Republican (YouTube video) who’s long seemed like one of the few decent human beings on the Hill, though there’ve always been places where one could quibble with his record. But this is just shameful. John Hostettler, of Indiana’s firecely contested “bloody eighth” district, is another antiwar but pro-torture Republican. His opponent is a pro-war Democrat. Thanks to Hostettler’s “coercive interrogation” vote, though, I hope the Dem wins just so his party gets closer to retaking the House, since that’s clearly the only thing that will stand between George W. Bush and Divine Right.

Meanwhile, in the Senate, not only did McCain, Lindsey Graham, and John Warner capitulate to Bush, they voted against an attempt to preserve executive detainees’ — which is what “enemy combatants” ought to be called, since the executive branch can decide arbitrarily who fits the “enemy combatant” bill — habeas corpus protections.

I’ve never felt so slimy to be an American. The Bush administration has been torturing and illegally holding people for years, of course, but without the fig leaf of law. Now waterboarding, stress positions, extended sleep deprivation (which, if you’re keeping people awake for days on end, may be more cruel than traditional thumbscrews), and a whole array of modern torture techniques are, at least implicitly, part of the law of the land. The rule of law has become the rule of the Marquis de Sade.

In all of this, the branch of the federal government that has acquitted itself best is the Supreme Court. Why are we supposed to want a Republican Senate and president again?


4 thoughts on “Bravo for Walter Jones, Goodbye Republic

  1. Tim September 29, 2006 / 6:19 am

    Hmmm. The URL for “Bovard’s Blog” looks incorrect. By the way your URL for Roderick Long in the blog roll is out of date.

  2. John Lowell September 29, 2006 / 8:45 pm

    I wouldn’t be confident in any way that a Democratic Congress will restrain the further implimentation of a Bush dictatorship, have they to this point?In any case it would seem that Bush will be restrained by no one if he so fancies, Congress, courts, you name it. Just today Gonzales warns judges just how it is that they are to treat a president in war time. Given another event like 9/11 and I’d question whether we’d likely even see an election in November. If they can consider it righteous to tortue they can consider righteous to rule by decree. Yesterday was a watershead in American history. We’ve lost our democracy.

    John Lowell

  3. Marcus Epstein October 3, 2006 / 2:07 am

    Jones and Duncan seem to be fighting for who is second best to Ron Paul in congress. Duncan opposed the war from the beginning, while Jones was serving up freedom fries. Duncan didn’t vote for the “we support Israel bombing hospitals” bill, while Jones did. Jones on the other hand has taken a much better leading role in opposing Amnesty for illegals, has been more vocally antiwar as of late, and doesn’t support torture.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s