Church and State as Seen From Glastonbury Tor

At the denouement of Auberon Waugh’s novel A Bed of Flowers (about a hippie commune set up on a Somerset farm by a drop-out businessman and his ex-Jesuit spiritual advisor), a certain Fr. Rasputian officiates at a triple wedding on the Glastonbury Tor. The nearby ruins of Glastonbury Abbey, despoiled by Henry VIII in the 16th century, elicit some thoughts from him on the prospects for Church and State:

There are those, of course, who maintain that the only thing which has really happened is that the State has won the argument; the Church as an institution now disintegrates before our eyes, while the State goes from strength to strength. Do not be deceived by appearances, my brothers and sisters. All that has happened is that the Church, with greater wisdom than our political masters can show, has decided to go underground. There are those who complain about the new order of services. The Mass, or what passes for the Mass, is now meaningless, ugly and an affront to religious sensibility. Nobody has yet understood that this may, through the ancient wisdom of the Church, be intentional, its purpose to discourage people from the empty gesture of church attendance, to drive them back on their inward spirituality, where all hope for the Church’s survival must reside. This is an age of formal distintegration, which the Church realises and the State does not. The State cannot realise it, since the State has no existence outside its form, unless you adduce the self-important and obsequious longings of a few indivdiuals as evidence of a soul. The Church is now engaged in a process of voluntary, formal distintegration, while the State is fighting the irresistaible forces of distintegration with more and more hyperbolical measures, unfounded in human aspirations or convenience, towards greater cohesion. Nobody can know what violence and what suffering will attend the State’s final disintegration, or for how long the wretched people who exercise their authority and feed their self-importance through the machinery of the State will manage to delay the moment, but of one thing we can be sure: when the moment of disintegration comes, the Church will re-emerge, through the will of the poeple and in response to their needs.

It’s a satirical novel, and this monologue is delivered by a character named “Rasputian” at that. Nevertheless, there’s good reason to think that at least a little of Auberon Waugh’s own view is reflected here. And there’s something to be said for it.


3 thoughts on “Church and State as Seen From Glastonbury Tor

  1. Tim August 28, 2006 / 10:43 am

    This reminds me of some comments from C.S. Lewis, who was both a Christian apologist and an opponent of what he called the “omnicompetent state”. I cannot find the exact quote but he said that in order to bring “post-Christian” man back to Christianity, it may be necessary to convert them back to paganism first. Lewis was once called a the Sneaky Pagan. There is some further discussion of Lewis’s views on paganism here.

  2. John Lowell August 28, 2006 / 4:21 pm

    Interesting that it’s “Rasputian” that speaks here. The whole thought that a disappearance into privacy might be a conscious contrivance of the Church couldn’t be more off the mark. It has been precisely the complaint of the Church that faith has been reduced to it’s private dimension that has propelled much of its modern criticism of the state, ideologies, etc.

    One senses as betrayed in this monologue a rather pronounced tendency to view Church and state as situated in a kind of side by side reality, one reminiscent of the two-tiered nature/grace formulation of a now long discredited neo-scholasticism. Might one soon expect from Fr. Neuhaus or Michael Novak an endorsement of “Rasputian’s” thesis? 🙂

  3. Michael B Dougherty August 29, 2006 / 9:31 pm

    I would love to believe this — instead I think the Churchmen running things have adopted alot of the bad habits we see everywhere else.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s